Disc cutters

sjs5060

sjs5060

Well-known member
My Makita disc cutter has given up the ghost, I’m not moaning it was 2nd hand circa 6 years ago and has, as was the previous Makita, been a good saw. Now the sensible thing is probably just go and buy another the same. I won’t entertain another make of petrol saw.

I am wondering though wether now is the time to switch to a battery one, I know it won’t be in the same league as far as performance goes but for what I actually use a disc cutter for will it be good enough? Sure if the saws in the van it’s used for all kinds but we do groundworks, the only time it’s pushed hard is when we’re doing what we should be using a floor saw for. Other than that is cutting the odd flag, manhole ring, pipe or mesh.

Ive also a breaker that’s ready for upgrade, again it occasional use, breaking into manholes and stuff, anything more than 20mins and I’m going for the mini digger breaker. Again anyone got any experience?

Any preferable makes? I’m a bit of a dewalt fan boy, have boots, pants etc, not because I’m that type of person but because I’ve never bought anything dewalt have put their name too and it not been good quality. For me it’s easier to buy something with a dewalt sticker on as I know it will do what I want and I don’t have to waste my time trying to swap about. That said because at the time dewalt didn’t do a cordless ratchet I’ve got some 12v milwaukee stuff and it’s good stuff, the 3/8 impact wrench is now the first thing I pick up in the workshop for anything under m16, it’s got some serious power and I find it nice to use.

I know changing brands means different batteries but ive currently no 54v dewalt stuff so I’d be buying batteries anyway. Dewalt are bringing a cordless Wacker out later in the year but that’s a different battery again 🤷🏻‍♂️

Whats everyone think? Has anyone tried battery stuff? Or shall I just be the forum guinea pig and try it so everyone else doesn’t have to
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
My Makita disc cutter has given up the ghost, I’m not moaning it was 2nd hand circa 6 years ago and has, as was the previous Makita, been a good saw. Now the sensible thing is probably just go and buy another the same. I won’t entertain another make of petrol saw.

I am wondering though wether now is the time to switch to a battery one, I know it won’t be in the same league as far as performance goes but for what I actually use a disc cutter for will it be good enough? Sure if the saws in the van it’s used for all kinds but we do groundworks, the only time it’s pushed hard is when we’re doing what we should be using a floor saw for. Other than that is cutting the odd flag, manhole ring, pipe or mesh.

Ive also a breaker that’s ready for upgrade, again it occasional use, breaking into manholes and stuff, anything more than 20mins and I’m going for the mini digger breaker. Again anyone got any experience?

Any preferable makes? I’m a bit of a dewalt fan boy, have boots, pants etc, not because I’m that type of person but because I’ve never bought anything dewalt have put their name too and it not been good quality. For me it’s easier to buy something with a dewalt sticker on as I know it will do what I want and I don’t have to waste my time trying to swap about. That said because at the time dewalt didn’t do a cordless ratchet I’ve got some 12v milwaukee stuff and it’s good stuff, the 3/8 impact wrench is now the first thing I pick up in the workshop for anything under m16, it’s got some serious power and I find it nice to use.

I know changing brands means different batteries but ive currently no 54v dewalt stuff so I’d be buying batteries anyway. Dewalt are bringing a cordless Wacker out later in the year but that’s a different battery again 🤷🏻‍♂️

Whats everyone think? Has anyone tried battery stuff? Or shall I just be the forum guinea pig and try it so everyone else doesn’t have to
not that I know anything :giggle: but the history speaks for itself ..... how many batteries are you likely to buy in 6 years and how often will you curse them being flat when you want to use it, or run out of steam, halfway through ... yet to see a gallon can full of lectrickery :rolleyes: ..... my couple of penny worth
 
sjs5060

sjs5060

Well-known member
not that I know anything :giggle: but the history speaks for itself ..... how many batteries are you likely to buy in 6 years and how often will you curse them being flat when you want to use it, or run out of steam, halfway through ... yet to see a gallon can full of lectrickery :rolleyes: ..... my couple of penny worth
it is the most likely outcome but there’s no prizes for carting petrol about, and that can run out too, and apparently your average groundworker is incapable of mixing the oil right, even tho theyve been at it 30yrs 🤦🏻
 
6

6feetdown

Well-known member
I think still at the moment I'd stick to petrol or genny and electric. The big battery stuff is so expensive for the time that you get out of a battery.
If money isn't an issue battery is worth a go
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
it is the most likely outcome but there’s no prizes for carting petrol about, and that can run out too, and apparently your average groundworker is incapable of mixing the oil right, even tho theyve been at it 30yrs 🤦🏻
I had some 'one shot' bottles arrive with my new Husqy hedge trimmer and blower ... one little bottle per 5 litres (100ml) .... kept the bottles and just refill ... even Pam can mix up 5 litres then :rolleyes: ... not that she's dull, but it's the perfect volume and so easy .. I doubt the one shot bottles are cheap, but if realistic, buy a box
alternatively buy some 100ml syringes - POP to get it right
 
JerryRtilt

JerryRtilt

Well-known member
Changed my saw not long ago, love the idea of battery power for the convenience, no starting problems, no air filters no mixing fuel etc but still couldn’t justify the cost, maybe next time around 🤔
 
B

Brendan

Well-known member
I used my mates Milwaukee cut off saw the other day, not a bad bit of kit, needs the high out put batteries though. Cuts less than 20mm off of a 300mm petrol cut off saw, is very light and easy to use.

If you have 18v DeWalt kit then jumping to the 54v saw isn't too bad as the batteries will work on the 18v stuff. The 54v batteries are badged as 18v in either 6,9 or 12ah so the 54v rating is a third

My Stihl saw after being sat for a few weeks has decided to smoke like a chimney again so might go for an 18v milwaukee
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
Yeah i guess in 12years time Makita may have caught up 😉
we'll all be running gear on water by then ..... after the oil companies wheel out all the various tech.s that they have suppressed for decades :mad:
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
I used my mates Milwaukee cut off saw the other day, not a bad bit of kit, needs the high out put batteries though. Cuts less than 20mm off of a 300mm petrol cut off saw, is very light and easy to use.

If you have 18v DeWalt kit then jumping to the 54v saw isn't too bad as the batteries will work on the 18v stuff. The 54v batteries are badged as 18v in either 6,9 or 12ah so the 54v rating is a third

My Stihl saw after being sat for a few weeks has decided to smoke like a chimney again so might go for an 18v milwaukee
oil separated out in the bottom of the tank ..... give it a good wobble :giggle::giggle:
 
B

Brendan

Well-known member
oil separated out in the bottom of the tank ..... give it a good wobble :giggle::giggle:
At some point I'll empty the tank and put some fresh mixed fuel in, hopefully that will be ok, if not another carb and time to get shot
 
sjs5060

sjs5060

Well-known member


theres not a great deal in it price wise tbf
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better


theres not a great deal in it price wise tbf
Mak one is 300mm ... other is 230mm ... need to compare like for like Ste and additional batteries are 200 quid a pop, so need two to run it and two on charge (and a second charger) :rolleyes:
 
6

6feetdown

Well-known member


theres not a great deal in it price wise tbf
Ah I thought you were after a 300 or 350mm one. The smaller ones id definitely give a go
 
sjs5060

sjs5060

Well-known member
Ah I thought you were after a 300 or 350mm one. The smaller ones id definitely give a go
I’m not completely decided tbh, the times I need to run a 300mm saw full depth are rare, if we’re cutting for a trench the floor saw is much more pleasant to use 🤷🏻‍♂️

a 300mm cordless is a lot of money, wouldn’t be so bad if there where some battery cross over, if the same battery would run saw, breaker, wacker and cement mixer I’d probably jump in with both feet. There’s nothing better than stuff that’s quiet
 
Top