Gunns Contractors Ltd

Grahams

Grahams

Don't complain - suggest what's better
Great dumpers. Very flexible being able to side tip. Thought you might have gone for the high tip swivel to cover all bases.
I saw one similar to yours with some lanscapers last year and they had fitted low ground pressure turf tyres which was working really well on a grass sports pitch.
 
Gunners

Gunners

Well-known member
Similar thought process to me when buying my 1.8t tracker dumper. Looks a handy tool

How much was it?

I paid £16k +vat.

Out of interest for other readers, dumper prices are currently,
£14,200 for 1t hightip Thwaites
£14,900 for 1t hightip JCB (with road lights)
£12k for 2t straight tip manual Thwaites
£17,293 for 2t straight tip hydrostatic Thwaites
£15,728 for 2t swivel manual Thwaites
£17936 for 2.3t hydrostatic swivel Thwaites
£12,750 for 3t straight tip manual Thwaites
£16,600 for 3t hydrostatic straight tip JCB (with road lights)

These were the best prices I got quoted, the 2t manual Thwaites ranged from £12-£14,400 so it paid to shop around for some models. My 1.5t swivel only differed a couple of hundred between the 3 dealers I tried. And if you add road lights to any of the Thwaites its a £500 upwards extra. So that makes the JCB's more competitive but still expensive considering the name and resale value of Thwaites.
I would imagine Mecalec are pretty competitive but I don't like their dumpers - especially the swivels. Really odd shaped skip, so didn't get quoted on them. Prices current as of May 2020.
 
doobin

doobin

Well-known member
I paid £16k +vat.

Out of interest for other readers, dumper prices are currently,
£14,200 for 1t hightip Thwaites
£14,900 for 1t hightip JCB (with road lights)
£12k for 2t straight tip manual Thwaites
£17,293 for 2t straight tip hydrostatic Thwaites
£15,728 for 2t swivel manual Thwaites
£17936 for 2.3t hydrostatic swivel Thwaites
£12,750 for 3t straight tip manual Thwaites
£16,600 for 3t hydrostatic straight tip JCB (with road lights)

These were the best prices I got quoted, the 2t manual Thwaites ranged from £12-£14,400 so it paid to shop around for some models. My 1.5t swivel only differed a couple of hundred between the 3 dealers I tried. And if you add road lights to any of the Thwaites its a £500 upwards extra. So that makes the JCB's more competitive but still expensive considering the name and resale value of Thwaites.
I would imagine Mecalec are pretty competitive but I don't like their dumpers - especially the swivels. Really odd shaped skip, so didn't get quoted on them. Prices current as of May 2020.
Almost makes my 1.8t tracked machine look cheap at 15.2k! Mind you the swivel to version would have been 19k. Mine is 3 way too which is handy but swivel would be even better.

Dumpers are annoying- they cost as much or more than the equivalent digger but there’s nothing like the same amount of complexity in them to justify the cost and it’s a struggle to get any hire rate for them sometimes!
 
Mogman

Mogman

What man as done, man can do, what never has,maybe
Very rare machine didn’t even know they made a 1.5 tonne on a 1 tonne chassis looks the business👍👍
 
Gunners

Gunners

Well-known member
Dumpers are annoying- they cost as much or more than the equivalent digger but there’s nothing like the same amount of complexity in them to justify the cost and it’s a struggle to get any hire rate for them sometimes!

Indeed, I was considering replacing my 8015 which is getting on a bit now, and for 16k I could have bought a nice shiny new JCB 18z with 3 years warranty and servicing. A tempting offer but the reality is, I can only drive one machine at a time and the dumper can be paired with either machine and earn that bit on top/ save me hire money. So as long as it doesnt get stolen, it stands to earn well over the next 20 years. Its a long term investment for sure.
 
Grahams

Grahams

Don't complain - suggest what's better
Would it be considered bad form to add gready boards so you could get a genuine 1.5t load? Dumper skips never seem big enough to carry the rated load, especially if you don't want to lose any.
 
Gunners

Gunners

Well-known member
Would it be considered bad form to add gready boards so you could get a genuine 1.5t load? Dumper skips never seem big enough to carry the rated load, especially if you don't want to lose any.
I did think about doing this for maximum production. This guy has done it with his, and its a good idea, but I would at least paint mine!
 

Attachments

  • Thwaites_1,5_tonne_MACH203_dumper.jpg
    Thwaites_1,5_tonne_MACH203_dumper.jpg
    170.7 KB · Views: 298
pettsy

pettsy

Well-known member
I have seen a couple on eBay, what kind of height is the skip compared to say a 1t high tip?
 
Furniss

Furniss

Well-known member
Neat little dumper - little skip means a lot of jumping between machines though - some detachable greedy board perhaps ?
 
GazCro

GazCro

Well-known member
Whilst my old fella was still in charge we must have done several kms of footpaths in the local area. All hardcore led with 1 ton dumpers due to access. We used greedy boards a lot but it adds a lot of weight high up. You'd wanna keep then for your own use
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
I did think about doing this for maximum production. This guy has done it with his, and its a good idea, but I would at least paint mine!
are they thick enough :oops: ... must be over hundred kilos of steel there
very nice looking tool Boyo ... like a baby version of my 6t Alldrive .... should serve you very well (y):cool:
 
GazCro

GazCro

Well-known member
are they thick enough :oops: ... must be over hundred kilos of steel there
very nice looking tool Boyo ... like a baby version of my 6t Alldrive .... should serve you very well (y):cool:
I just made mine out of plywood drilled couple of holes through top edge of skip bolt them on as needed. Last a good while easy made again
 
Neilporteous

Neilporteous

Active member
Very nice dumper, that would be handy if there was such a thing as high tip swivel, any idea if theres such a thing?
As others have said, its an expensive investment when you compare to a digger but still worth the while in the long run.
 
Quattromike

Quattromike

Well member-known
. So as long as it doesnt get stolen, it stands to earn well over the next 20 years. Its a long term investment for sure.
with a new bit of kit like this do you fit a plant tracker / alarm system / secret kill switch to give it some chance with the upcoming recession looming 🤓.
 
J

Jimoz

Well-known member
Very nice dumper, that would be handy if there was such a thing as high tip swivel, any idea if theres such a thing?
As others have said, its an expensive investment when you compare to a digger but still worth the while in the long run.
I've had 3t swivel hi tip, hydrostatic
1.jpg
 
hiluxman

hiluxman

Well-known member
Very nice dumper, that would be handy if there was such a thing as high tip swivel, any idea if theres such a thing?
As others have said, its an expensive investment when you compare to a digger but still worth the while in the long run.
Yes there is, i almost bought one a month or two ago, but money got spent on somthing else.
 
K

Komatsu

Well-known member
Crazy times at the moment. Seem to be flat out with work to do and price, and the phone just wont stop ringing! Thought the lockdown would send things the other way but I'm doing my best to ride the wave while it lasts. In light of the work I've got lined up, I thought it was time I bought a newer dumper. The old 3t Thwaites has served well but I need something I can fit on my plant trailer really, something a bit smaller and more handy for the finishing work and landscaping I tend to spend most of my time on. After debating the usual 1t, 2t, 3t size question, I decided to go for a rather rare beast, a seed that was planted in my head at last years plantworks.

So I would like to introduce you all to my new 1.5t swivel powered wheelbarrow! Picked up last week.

Its the same length as the standard 1t high tip but with wider axels and skip. Takes 5 grading buckets to fill which isnt a huge amount, but at 1.3m wide, it goes behind the 8026 and most importantly for me, will fit down the footpaths I regularly build, whilst also having a bigger capacity than the standard 1t I usually hire for these jobs. 80% of my work is on tight sites with poor access and with this, if I can get the 8026 in there, I can get the dumper in. It should also work well when paired with my 8015.
If I need to do some proper muckshifting, I will hire a 3t for peanuts. But this should be a good compromise a lot of the time on my kinda work. And it looks really good with the wider track on the small chassis (y)
Had to buy new as they just don't come up 2nd hand and I hope to keep it forever so the purchase price should become irrelevant (yes it was expensive for a wheelbarrow).
Very smart Ollie, hope we’re going to get a 📽 review on it😀
 
Top