Hydraulic thumb.

M

Monkeybusiness

Well-known member
🤣 where did you get your stone from (chris Tomlinson) and what you doing with it. Are pikey barrier
Off a job in Bury - there was an old mill on site many moons ago apparently, and there are still a few odd lumps knocking around.
It’ll end up as a feature when I do my garden (but need to sort the house first!).
 
Giles

Giles

Well-known member
A few thumbs in watts auction
 

Attachments

  • 04F63BAD-B066-471E-934B-FBAC5ED80ACF.png
    04F63BAD-B066-471E-934B-FBAC5ED80ACF.png
    370.5 KB · Views: 215
William127

William127

Well-known member
Rsl thumb on.my cx15, makes life much easier for such a cheap attachment and gives ridiculous lifting/shifting power for the machine size. This is the second 1.5 I've had one of these on, moved hundreds of tons with them.👍
I tend to take it off if I'm digging but takes seconds to put back on👍
 

Attachments

  • 20221111_120028.jpg
    20221111_120028.jpg
    229.4 KB · Views: 140
  • 20221111_120022.jpg
    20221111_120022.jpg
    197.2 KB · Views: 138
  • 20221111_122653.jpg
    20221111_122653.jpg
    252 KB · Views: 157
Storrsy

Storrsy

Well-known member
Rsl thumb on.my cx15, makes life much easier for such a cheap attachment and gives ridiculous lifting/shifting power for the machine size. This is the second 1.5 I've had one of these on, moved hundreds of tons with them.👍
I tend to take it off if I'm digging but takes seconds to put back on👍


Nice but would you not be better of with it being a hydraulic one? to my mind the convenience of a thumb is the ability to quickly flip it out when you need it and return it when you don't. I can see if your taking it on and off altogether there is some benefit of being manual but would have thought you'd not have to take it off if it was hydraulic. Mine has only come off once in 2 years of having it and that was to relieve a bit of weight when I was doing some very steep post knocker work but otherwise I just leave it on and disconnect the hoses if I need the aux supply
 
William127

William127

Well-known member
Nice but would you not be better of with it being a hydraulic one? to my mind the convenience of a thumb is the ability to quickly flip it out when you need it and return it when you don't. I can see if your taking it on and off altogether there is some benefit of being manual but would have thought you'd not have to take it off if it was hydraulic. Mine has only come off once in 2 years of having it and that was to relieve a bit of weight when I was doing some very steep post knocker work but otherwise I just leave it on and disconnect the hoses if I need the aux supply
I gave it a lot of thought when I bought this second one and decided that it wasn't worth it for my use, it really does take next to no time to adjust/remove. A lot of my jobs it'll be sat on the trailer the whole job, like if I'm digging out and back filling for paving. But I wouldn't want to leave the yard without it.
There are a lot of times where I'd like the hydraulic for the extra adjustment for picking up odd shaped pieces though.
 
doobin

doobin

Well-known member
I gave it a lot of thought when I bought this second one and decided that it wasn't worth it for my use, it really does take next to no time to adjust/remove. A lot of my jobs it'll be sat on the trailer the whole job, like if I'm digging out and back filling for paving. But I wouldn't want to leave the yard without it.
There are a lot of times where I'd like the hydraulic for the extra adjustment for picking up odd shaped pieces though.
If you're leaving it on the trailer then you might as well go the whole hog and buy a grab. Intermecatto are the best for a mini.
 
Storrsy

Storrsy

Well-known member
If you're leaving it on the trailer then you might as well go the whole hog and buy a grab. Intermecatto are the best for a mini.
I was using my grab on the 8 tonner the other day to tidy up the yard and I have to say I just can't take to it all. I've used selector grabs to on other machines and fine myself getting frustrated. Can't be doing with all the swapping around. Can't dig out stumps with it, anything that I want to do with it feels like it's would be rough on the rotate like wrestling a large rock out of a pile. So yeah it's great for handling timber and rehandling rocks but then that's about it. Job I'm about to start in a week's time. I'll be clearing scrub, digging out boulders, raking and pilling up a large area of bramble, digging out an access track clearing trees as we go etc. Got an 2 acres of fallen willow to clear and burn etc, dig out all the stumps etc.Now I know if I had a thumb on this machine I could turn up and do all of that with nothing but thumb and the biggest digging bucket, perhaps a narrow bucket for when it comes to piling up timber. But I dont so it's going to be endless swapping between digger buckets and the grab. Then I think about the price of that grab new (£8k) and the price of a thumb (£1k). Just doesn't add up for me. More stuff to bring along on the lorry too
 

Attachments

  • IMG-20221204-WA0000.jpeg
    IMG-20221204-WA0000.jpeg
    160.3 KB · Views: 137
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
I was using my grab on the 8 tonner the other day to tidy up the yard and I have to say I just can't take to it all. I've used selector grabs to on other machines and fine myself getting frustrated. Can't be doing with all the swapping around. Can't dig out stumps with it, anything that I want to do with it feels like it's would be rough on the rotate like wrestling a large rock out of a pile. So yeah it's great for handling timber and rehandling rocks but then that's about it. Job I'm about to start in a week's time. I'll be clearing scrub, digging out boulders, raking and pilling up a large area of bramble, digging out an access track clearing trees as we go etc. Got an 2 acres of fallen willow to clear and burn etc, dig out all the stumps etc.Now I know if I had a thumb on this machine I could turn up and do all of that with nothing but thumb and the biggest digging bucket, perhaps a narrow bucket for when it comes to piling up timber. But I dont so it's going to be endless swapping between digger buckets and the grab. Then I think about the price of that grab new (£8k) and the price of a thumb (£1k). Just doesn't add up for me. More stuff to bring along on the lorry too
know where you're coming from, but that's a digging grab isn't it ... should deal with the stumps and boulders OK .... rest as you say is a bucket job ideally
 
JD450A

JD450A

Feral as Fk 🐾
I was using my grab on the 8 tonner the other day to tidy up the yard and I have to say I just can't take to it all. I've used selector grabs to on other machines and fine myself getting frustrated. Can't be doing with all the swapping around. Can't dig out stumps with it, anything that I want to do with it feels like it's would be rough on the rotate like wrestling a large rock out of a pile. So yeah it's great for handling timber and rehandling rocks but then that's about it. Job I'm about to start in a week's time. I'll be clearing scrub, digging out boulders, raking and pilling up a large area of bramble, digging out an access track clearing trees as we go etc. Got an 2 acres of fallen willow to clear and burn etc, dig out all the stumps etc.Now I know if I had a thumb on this machine I could turn up and do all of that with nothing but thumb and the biggest digging bucket, perhaps a narrow bucket for when it comes to piling up timber. But I dont so it's going to be endless swapping between digger buckets and the grab. Then I think about the price of that grab new (£8k) and the price of a thumb (£1k). Just doesn't add up for me. More stuff to bring along on the lorry too

Trouble is your not being rough enough
 
Storrsy

Storrsy

Well-known member
know where you're coming from, but that's a digging grab isn't it ... should deal with the stumps and boulders OK .... rest as you say is a bucket job ideally
You can't really give it enough s**t though to pull out stumps. It forces the rotate around etc which I don't like doing. Same if I have a load of boulders in a heap it all has to be dismantled carefully before I can get the one I'm after. I just prefer the robustness of a bucket and thumb. You'd have to be a real animal to damage that...
 
Mogman

Mogman

What man as done, man can do, what never has,maybe
You can't really give it enough s**t though to pull out stumps. It forces the rotate around etc which I don't like doing. Same if I have a load of boulders in a heap it all has to be dismantled carefully before I can get the one I'm after. I just prefer the robustness of a bucket and thumb. You'd have to be a real animal to damage that...
I’ve bought a few hydraulic thumbs (3 of them🤔) only need one🤷 if your interested PM me I’m collecting them tomorrow
 
Top