torque wrench

V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
thats neat 💭👍
also do a 1/2" one too
1767891992008.png
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
whats the snag do you think ?
access ?
have given some thought as to their use at the top end of an extension and can't see that it'd be an issue as the same torque would be transferred down the length of the bar - I think? :unsure: --- 's an interesting conundrum :unsure:
 
Mogman

Mogman

What man as done, man can do, what never has,maybe
have given some thought as to their use at the top end of an extension and can't see that it'd be an issue as the same torque would be transferred down the length of the bar - I think? :unsure: --- 's an interesting conundrum :unsure:
I think the extension would twist to a degree🤔 so wouldn’t give a true reading🤔 maybe🤔
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
I think the extension would twist to a degree🤔 so wouldn’t give a true reading🤔 maybe🤔
's what I'm trying to decide, but'd need the same level of torque to do that - can't get my head around it TBH
 
Bri963

Bri963

Well-known member
I think the extension would twist to a degree🤔 so wouldn’t give a true reading🤔 maybe🤔
Definitely. Low torque it’s negligible but when you start pulling 200+ Nm on foot of 1/2” extension it does make a difference. We tried it at work to settle a discussion. It’s when you’re getting near to the point where the extension physically can’t handle the torque and is getting towards its elastic limit.
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
Definitely. Low torque it’s negligible but when you start pulling 200+ Nm on foot of 1/2” extension it does make a difference. We tried it at work to settle a discussion. It’s when you’re getting near to the point where the extension physically can’t handle the torque and is getting towards its elastic limit.
was thinking more along the lines of a stumpy 2" or 3" extension to get the unit away from the socket ... a 12" would without doubt flex big time
 
Gecko

Gecko

Well-known member
the same torque would be transferred down the length of the bar - I think? :unsure:
Yes.

Just a mind game, but think of it like this:
First thought is that with an extension, the gauge will read low.
To test this theory, add say 10m of extensions - it should read much lower
Add enough extensions and eventually, regardless of the input torque, the other end would be zero.

Obviously this 'just ain't going to happen', so "input = output" .

Yes it will flex, but when the movement stops, the torque will the same.
 
Mogman

Mogman

What man as done, man can do, what never has,maybe
Yes.

Just a mind game, but think of it like this:
First thought is that with an extension, the gauge will read low.
To test this theory, add say 10m of extensions - it should read much lower
Add enough extensions and eventually, regardless of the input torque, the other end would be zero.

Obviously this 'just ain't going to happen', so "input = output" .

Yes it will flex, but when the movement stops, the torque will the same.
That’s a bit like the rotating shaft I discussed years ago

Looking at end of a shaft rotating the top runs to the right to bottom runs to the left therefore the centre is stationary🤔 but if it is the whole shaft won’t be turning 😳
 
V8Druid

V8Druid

do it as well as you can,but learn to do it better
That’s a bit like the rotating shaft I discussed years ago

Looking at end of a shaft rotating the top runs to the right to bottom runs to the left therefore the centre is stationary🤔 but if it is the whole shaft won’t be turning 😳
even at molecular level the centre will still be rotating - just can't see it Mog ;)
 
Gecko

Gecko

Well-known member
That’s a bit like the rotating shaft I discussed years ago

Looking at end of a shaft rotating the top runs to the right to bottom runs to the left therefore the centre is stationary🤔 but if it is the whole shaft won’t be turning 😳
From an engineering point of view, you can make good use from that observation - if the material at the centre of the shaft arrears not to move, then it is not contributing (significantly) the the strength of the shaft - either in bending or torque loading.
If the centre of the shaft doesn't help you, then you can leave it out - literally.
A hollow shaft has almost as much strength as a solid, but significant weight and materials savings.
 
Top